A white background with a few lines on it

Why the NBA Has Lost Its Edge: A Fan’s Brutally Honest Take

AJ Oberlender • January 14, 2025

From three-point overload to softer gameplay and accessibility woes—here’s what’s killing basketball’s soul.

A little girl standing in front of a miami arena

You know that friend who says, “I don’t watch the NBA anymore because it’s too woke”? Yeah, that guy? He’s wrong. The NBA isn’t losing viewers because players have opinions—it’s losing viewers because the game’s lost its bite. It’s gone soft, predictable, and hard to access. And for fans like me, who grew up on Heat-Knicks brawls and Pistons-level violence, that’s a tough pill to swallow.


Let’s break this down. Because it’s not one problem—it’s all the problems.


Remember When Basketball Was a Blood Sport?


Back in the day, the NBA was basically hockey without the ice. Watching the Heat and Knicks in the '90s was like tuning into a street fight that just happened to involve a basketball. Alonzo Mourning and Larry Johnson weren’t afraid to throw down. Jeff Van Gundy? The man clung to Zo’s leg during a fight, and it’s still one of the greatest NBA moments of all time. That rivalry wasn’t just entertainment—it was a masterclass in why hate fuels sports.


And it wasn’t just them. The Pistons weren’t the “Bad Boys” because it sounded cool. They beat people up. Michael Jordan had to earn his championships by taking elbows to the ribs every time he drove the lane. The Celtics and Lakers? Those guys genuinely despised each other. Magic and Bird weren’t out here swapping jerseys and planning vacations; they were trying to end each other’s dynasties.


Fast forward to today, and what do we have? Guys high-fiving each other mid-game. Hugging after free throws. It’s like watching a bunch of coworkers at a team-building retreat. Where’s the fire? Where’s the grit?


The Three-Point Snoozefest


Let’s talk about the three-pointer. It used to be a weapon. Now it’s the whole damn arsenal. Steph Curry broke the game, and that was fun for a while. But now? Everyone’s out here shooting like they’re Steph—and spoiler alert: they’re not.


You’ve got teams throwing up 50 threes a game, and half of them barely graze the rim. The mid-range game? Dead. Post moves? Extinct. Watching a game now feels like you’re stuck in a time loop: dribble, kick out, shoot a three, repeat. It’s like the NBA forgot that variety is what made basketball exciting in the first place.


Look, I get it. Analytics say threes are the most efficient shot. But sports aren’t supposed to be a math problem. They’re supposed to make you feel something. And watching a team chuck bricks from 27 feet doesn’t exactly scream “edge-of-your-seat excitement.”


The Accessibility Dumpster Fire


Now, let’s address the elephant in the room: how the hell are you even supposed to watch these games? Back in the day, you flipped on your TV, and boom—there’s the game. Now? It’s a nightmare.


You’ve got blackouts, streaming restrictions, and about 47 different subscription services you need to juggle. Oh, you live in Miami and want to watch the Heat? Sorry, you’re blacked out. But hey, here’s a nice highlight reel on Instagram. It’s like the NBA doesn’t want us to watch live games anymore.


Here’s an idea, Adam Silver: make it simple. Let fans watch any game, live, without jumping through hoops. Charge us a flat fee, and we’ll happily fork over the cash. Because right now, the NBA’s accessibility issues are driving people straight into the arms of TikTok highlights and YouTube recaps.


Players: Brand Ambassadors First, Superstars Second


Normally, I’d say people follow people, not brands. But in sports? It’s flipped. Fans are loyal to the team—the brand—not the player. Giants fans didn’t jump ship to the Eagles when Saquon left, and Heat fans didn’t follow Wade to Cleveland. Sure, players like LeBron transcend teams, but they’re the rare exceptions.


Most players are ambassadors for their team’s brand. And when they go rogue or toxic, like Jimmy Butler seems to be doing right now, fans turn on them. It’s not personal—it’s about the team. Players need to realize their loyalty is part of what fans buy into. Quit on the brand, and you’re quitting on the fans.


The NBA should remind players that contracts aren’t just about talent—they’re about representing the team. Fans will stay Heat fans, with or without Jimmy. The question is: does he want to be part of the legacy, or the guy who walked away?


Trash Talk: A Lost Art


What’s also missing today is the attitude. Michael Jordan wasn’t just the GOAT because of his skills—he was a psychological assassin. He’d tell you exactly how he was going to destroy you, then do it with a smile. Larry Bird once walked into a locker room before a three-point contest and asked who was coming in second. Reggie Miller? He had Spike Lee so rattled during a playoff game that Spike was basically a spectator for the rest of the series.


Now? Everyone’s friends. Don’t get me wrong, camaraderie is great, but can we keep it for the offseason? I don’t want to see opponents laughing and hugging during a timeout. I want fire. I want drama. I want to believe these guys actually careabout beating each other.


The “Woke” Excuse is Lazy


Let’s clear something up: the NBA didn’t lose viewers because it “went woke.” The league’s always been socially conscious. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar was advocating for civil rights when most people were still figuring out how to spell “activism.” Players having opinions isn’t new, and it’s not what’s driving fans away.


The problem isn’t that players speak out—it’s that the product on the court isn’t compelling enough to keep fans locked in. If the games were as intense and unpredictable as they were in the '90s, no one would care what LeBron tweets. They’d be too busy arguing about whether his team could get past the Celtics.


How to Fix the NBA


Alright, enough ranting. Here’s how we fix this mess:

  1. Bring Back Physicality
    Let defenders play defense again. Nobody wants a foul every 12 seconds. Let the game get rough. Let players feel the stakes.
  2. Tone Down the Threes
    Reward diverse offensive play. Make the mid-range and post-game valuable again. Balance is exciting; monotony isn’t.
  3. Fix Accessibility
    Kill the blackouts. One streaming service for every game, live, anywhere. No exceptions.
  4. Hold Players Accountable
    If you sign a contract, honor it. The NBA needs to step up and enforce this. Don’t let stars quit on their teams halfway through. Fans deserve more.
  5. Foster Real Rivalries
    The buddy-buddy act is cute, but sports thrive on conflict. Trash talk, on-court scuffles, and pride in crushing your opponent—those are the ingredients that make fans invest. Encourage that. Rivalries aren’t born out of handshakes; they’re forged in battles.
  6. Protect the Product
    Players like Jimmy Butler can’t be allowed to coast through games while angling for a trade. The league needs to implement stricter rules or penalties for this kind of behavior. Maybe it’s reducing guaranteed money when players publicly quit on their teams. Maybe it’s tightening trade rules. Whatever it is, it needs to make players think twice before bailing out on their contracts.


The Soul of the NBA is on the Line


As a die-hard Miami Heat fan, I miss when basketball felt like a war. I miss when players fought for every possession like their lives depended on it. The NBA today feels like it’s coasting on its past glory, hoping flashy dunks and viral highlights will keep fans engaged. But here’s the thing: they won’t.


Fans want to feel something—tension, excitement, maybe even a little fear. They want rivalries, drama, and unpredictability. That’s what made the NBA a cultural phenomenon. And if the league can’t find a way to bring that back, the slide in viewership is only going to get worse.


So, Adam Silver, if you’re reading this (and let’s be real, you should be), it’s time to act. The NBA doesn’t need to reinvent itself—it needs to remember what made it great in the first place. And for the love of all that’s holy, let me watch my Heat games without needing a tech support hotline.

A collage of four photos of miami heat basketball players
By AJ Oberlender January 17, 2025
Explore the Miami Heat’s reintroduction of the Vice jerseys—NBA’s best city branding—timed perfectly with Jimmy Butler’s return. A celebration of Miami’s flair and resilience.
A photo of a woman and two children taken in 1967
By AJ Oberlender January 12, 2025
Discover the inspiring story of my grandmother, Buba Luba, as we celebrate her 93rd birthday. From her journey as an immigrant to her lessons on forgiveness, family, and resilience, her wisdom continues to shape our lives.
A man in a purple hat is talking to a group of football players
By AJ Oberlender January 7, 2025
Fantasy football is more than just a game—it’s a masterclass in leadership and strategy. In this post, I explore how managing a fantasy roster taught me lessons in decision-making, adaptability, and collaboration that apply in the boardroom and beyond. Whether you’re running a team or a business, the skills are universal.
A man is lighting a candle for a little girl in a high chair.
By AJ Oberlender January 1, 2025
This eighth and final night of Chanukah, I reflect on a week of candles lit across five locations, family moments that felt like miracles, and the timeless lessons from my parents’ first menorah. Chag Sameach from our family to yours!
A person is sitting in front of a window with a menorah in the background.
By AJ Oberlender December 31, 2024
Discover how the timeless lessons of Chanukkah—resilience, community, and finding light in darkness—can guide and inspire you all year long. Keep the flame alive beyond the eight days!
A woman is playing a game of dreidel with coins on a table.
By AJ Oberlender December 30, 2024
On the sixth night of Chanukah, discover how the dreidel teaches us about life’s twists and turns. From work wins to Marlins heartbreaks, every spin has a lesson!
A woman is sitting at a desk with a laptop and a cell phone
By AJ Oberlender December 29, 2024
Discover the inspiring lesson of Chanukah: how small victories in the daily grind can lead to big successes. Embrace resilience, celebrate progress, and find your light in the darkest moments. 🕎
A group of people are walking through an airport terminal.
By AJ Oberlender December 28, 2024
A missing dress, a chaotic family morning, and a 4th-night Chanukah miracle—discover how the joy of balagan brought light and laughter to our holiday celebration.
A family is sitting in a tent reading a book.
By AJ Oberlender December 27, 2024
Discover 5 powerful marketing lessons inspired by Chanukah! Learn how brands can build trust, spark surprise, and foster community to keep audiences engaged—just like the holiday keeps us hooked for 8 days.
A menorah with a bunch of lit candles on it
By AJ Oberlender December 26, 2024
Discover why every business needs a ‘shamash’—the leader who empowers their team to thrive without burning out. Learn how sustainable leadership can light up your organization and keep your spark alive.
Show More